Video Vignettes ID: 3214

Asking for Contrary Evidence

The Key to Accurate Hiring: Unveiling Contradictory Evidence

When an interviewer begins to get a one-sided impression, they may tend to ask questions that will confirm their negative impressions. This should raise a red flag that the “gut feeling” is still at work. If an interviewer thinks that a candidate has all the required job skills, they will tend to ask questions that confirm their impressions. The reverse is also true.

Additional Information

When an interviewer thinks a candidate has all the wrong skills or behaviors, they may tend to ask questions that confirm their negative impressions. Sometimes all that’s needed is to step back, regain perspective, and ask for contrary information.

For example, if all your interview questions have focused on situations that turned out well, you should ask questions that focus on situations in which things didn’t work out well. If you’re thinking this candidate truly “walks on water,” it’s time to ask for contrary information.

More From the Series: More Than a Gut Feeling™ The Structured Interview

Related Programs & Training Ideas

Competencies

  • Ensuring Professional & Compliant Behavior

Share This Page